Tuesday, September 19, 2006

Knowledge Integration is the key to providing effective and efficient health care service

The article, Just-in-Time Delivery Comes to Knowledge Management, brings up major issues regarding knowledge sharing and application. In a highly specialized application domain such as healthcare, both existence and usage of high-level expertise are crucial to the success of the healthcare system. While high-level expertise is typically owned by a small number of experts who develop their expertise through long years of practicing experience and learning, such expertise should be made available to and deployed by a relatively larger number of practicing physicians. It’s apparent that the availability of high-level expertise does not automatically means every physician gets to use it. Here is where KM technology can help tremendously.

A problem common to physicians is the great quantity of information and knowledge items. There are almost: 10,000 different diseases and syndromes, 3,000 medications, 1,100 lab ests, and many of the 400,000 articles added each year to the biomedical literature.

Partners HealthCare itself produces about 200 articles on hypertension, 139 on asthma, and 313 on diabetes. Lots of facts and information mean lots of knowledge is required to stay on top and know how to best match with the patients’ specific situation. This is overwhelming for left-alone physicians!

An effective treatment requires a perfect match among the characteristics in three categories: disease, medication, and patients. Doctors gather information about patients’ illness symptoms. Computer systems, especially database systems, record medication data and information, and experts know a lot about diseases. When these three categories of knowledge are properly integrated, only positive outcomes and no negative ones are produced.

Saturday, September 16, 2006

Nucor Steel vs. Partners HealthCare

The power of knowledge is often revealed in specific contexts. In a manufacturing setting where operational excellence is top priority, knowledge creation, sharing and application is a natural part of daily operation. Nucor Steel management and workers are proud of their products as a result of relentlessly pursuing zero-defect work outcome. Knowledge management practices are enthusiastically embraced because every body's compensation is determined by their work quality and productivity. For example, maximizing knowledge sharing is usually difficult if left to voluntary participation and no explicit incentive is provided. At Nucor Steel, however, it is a norm because only half of the bonus is based on individual performance, another half comes from group performance. To me, this is a smart design for it ties self interest and common interest together.

The daily operations of Partners HealthCare do not involve team work as thoroughly as those of Nucor Steel. Order entry, lab test ordering and online referral, for examples, mostly are decisions of individual physicians. The highly specialized nature of the knowledge required to achieve high accuracy and cost efficiency means the expertise of domain experts not only valuable but also scarce. But linking the domain experts' expertise to every physician's daily work, Partners HealtCare gets to improve its overall performance, in terms of better health care service and reduced operational cost.

At Nucor Steel, knowledge management primarily centers around people and management. Partners HealthCare, however, bakes knowledge into automatic systems. The people-orientation vs. system-orientation continuum provides a useful framework to analyze knowledge management implementation in the real world. Which approach is the best for the organizations looking for wisdom to enhance the possibility of success? The answer depends to a great degree on the nature of the settings.

Friday, September 08, 2006

Baking Knowledge into Work Practice

While most KM principles and frameworks are applicable to different sectors and industries, the design and implementation of KM initiatives must be adaptive to unique domain situations in order to succeed. The doctors in the Partners HealthCare use highly specialized, domain-specific knowledge to provide healthcare services. The knowledge base in particular and knowledge management program in general implemented to support their works also must exhibit high levels of expertise. Expertise comes from experts, well respected experts. Since experts in the medical field usually are not familiar with best ways to extract and formulate knowledge, someone familiar with knowledge acquisition and organization must work closely with them to transfer their medical expertise into computer-processible forms. According to the experience in expert system development, this is one of the major bottlenecks in the first-generation knowledge management systems development. The challenge in transferring highly specialized, domain-specific knowledge into computerized knowledge base can not be overly emphasized.
However, it's precisely because it's not a trivial matter, whoever doing it right gets to enjoy nontrivial benefits.
Once the first version is released for regular use, the system must be subject to ongoing update and maintenance. If not designed properly, the system structure can get more and more unwieldy as system size grows. This is another hurdle that must be jumped to keep the system working.

Wednesday, September 06, 2006

Knowledge Management is for Everybody


Knowledge management is an important issue for companies in all sectors. The knowledge/information component of the product/service offering often increases in order to obtain differentiation benefit in the knowledge economy. The experience of Nucor Steel demonstrates the crucial role everybody plays in bettering the entire company's competitive advantage. To them, human resource management measures matter as much as (in many cases even more than) technology deployment. When the management measures are consistently practiced, a knowledge-friendly organizational culture gradually emerges. Technology can be purchased, the use of technology can be unique and difficult to duplicate. Reputation earned through long years of excellence can be seriously challenged when customers are disappointed. Advantageous location is great, but only up to a certain extent. Look at in this Businessweek special report how people in the steel products manufacturing company get motivated to actively engage in continual innovation. Much inspiration can be drawn from this company for those who are contemplating where competitive advantage comes from.
http://www.businessweek.com/magazine/content/06_18/b3982075.htm?chan=search

Saturday, September 02, 2006

What is knowledge advantage?


An organization with knowledge advantage constantly increases or improves its knowledge stock, engages everybody in learning and innovation, and offers great value to its customers and other stakeholders as a result. Such an organization is a learning organization, an adaptive organization, and an intelligent organization. It is usually managed as a community guided by clearly communicated visions. Experimentation is a common way of life. Open discussions backed by mutual trust take place at every corner and acrosss organizational boundaries. Technologies are used to automate tedious and repetitive tasks. Communication and analysis technologies also allow knowledge workers to excercise creative thinking and to collaborate with each other on tough projects. An organization with knowledge advantage is an adaptive and open system, maximizing its collective inlligence to solve problems and produce value.

Driving Forces of Knowledge Management

Knowledge management is important for organizations because they must effectively respond to multiple challenges originating from both outside and inside the organization. These challenges include: increasing domain complexity, accelerating market volatility, intensified speed of responsiveness, diminishing individual experience, convergence of product and service, and the ubiquitous connectivity.

Effective management of valuable knowledge enables continuous value innovation. Innovative products and services come from innovative people working together in a knowlege-friendly environment. Such an environment involves visionary leadership, proactive and sensitive management, and powerful tools. The famous 80/20 principle works here: 80% of the efforts in knowledge management is organizational and people-related measures and 20% is technology. The significance of technology is determined by the size factors such as numbers of collaborating locations and people and other knowledge components. The larger the organization, the higher the importance of the technology.

Friday, September 01, 2006

What is knowledge?

Two resources are especially valuable for the discussion of definitions of knowledge. The first one is a textbook published couple of years ago:

Becerra-Fernandez, Irma, Gonzalez, Arlina, and Sabherwal, Rajiv. (2004). Knowledge Management: Challenges, Solutions, and Technolgies. Upper Saddle River, New Jersey: Pearson Prentice Hall (ISBN: 0-13-101606-7).

Its chapter-by-chapter Powerpoint slides can be found on its companion website (http://wps.prenhall.com/bp_becerra_km_1/0,9020,1264561-,00.html). Click on Chapter 2 (1) to look at how knowledge is related to data and information.

Another one is a very popular professional book written by two well-known scholars and management consultants, Thomas H. Davenport and Laurence Prusak. The title of the book is Working Knowledge - How Organizations Manage What They Know, published by Harvard Business School Press (ISBN: 1-57851-301-4). In this book, knowledge is defined as "a fluid mix of framed experience, values, contextual information, and expert insight that provides a framework for evaluating and incorporating new experiences and information. It originates and is applied in the minds of knowers. In organizations, it often becomes embedded not only in documents or repositories but also in organizational routines, processes, practices, and norms. (p. 3)"

Data is representation of facts. Data can be transformed into information by adding value in several ways:



  • Contextualized: for what purpose the data was gathered
  • Categorized: by units of analysis or key components of the data
  • Calculated: analyzed mathematically or statistically
  • Corrected: errors are removed
  • Condensed: summarized in a more concise form (2).

Transformation of data into information can be done automatically. However, the transformation of information into knowledge usually requires human efforts:

  • Comparison: how does this situation compare to other situations?
  • Consequences: implications of the information for decisions and actions
  • Connections: how this knowledge relate to others?
  • Conversation: what do other people think about this information?
Knowledge develops over time. Knowledge born of experience recognizes familiar patterns and can make connections between what is happening now and what happened then.

Knowledge is aware of what it doesn't know. It has been pointed out that the more knowledgeable one becomes, the more humble one feels about what one knows.

Unlike data and information, knowledge contains judgement. Once internalized, knowledge can exhibit its power in profound ways.

Knowledge even works through rules of thumb and intuition: felxible guides to action that developed through trial and error and over long experience and observation.

In a globalized economy, knowledge advantage may be company's greatest source of sustainable competitive advantage.

References:
1. Becerra-Fernandez, Irma, Gonzalez, Arlina, and Sabherwal, Rajiv. (2004). Knowledge Management: Challenges, Solutions, and Technolgies. Upper Saddle River, New Jersey: Pearson Prentice Hall.

2. Thomas H. Davenport and Laurence Prusak. (2000). Working Knowledge - How Organizations Manage What They Know. Boston, Massachusetts: Harvard Business School Press.